Family Style Dining for Groups of 20 or More

Join us for All-You-Care-to-Eat Family-Style Meal!

Since 1959, Plain & Fancy Restaurant is well-known for serving family-style dining in Lancaster County with PA Dutch favorites. Dining at Plain & Fancy Restaurant is for groups of 20 or more with advanced reservations only.


Amish Family-Style Menu (January – October)

  • Rolls with butter and coleslaw 
  • House salad with house dressing 
  • Fried chicken (assorted pieces), eye round of beef and beef meatloaf 
  • Mashed potatoes with gravy 
  • Brown buttered noodles 
  • Green beans 
  • Two desserts made in-house 
  • Beverages include iced tea, lemonade, water, coffee, hot tea 

NEW for 2024, the Holiday Feast menu (November-December): 

  • Rolls with butter and coleslaw 
  • Fried chicken, sliced roast turkey breast, and baked ham with au jus 
  • Mashed potatoes with gravy 
  • Stuffing 
  • Chef’s vegetable and cranberry sauce 
  • Miller’s made in-house apple pie and pumpkin pie 
  • Beverages include iced tea, lemonade, water, coffee, hot tea 


More on Family-Style Group Dining: Payment must be made on one master bill. One complimentary meal for the group leader and one complimentary meal for a professional motorcoach driver (if applicable) will be provided. Plain & Fancy Farm offers a large parking lot to accommodate motor coaches. Minimum group size is 20.

Make a reservation request (note: this is not a confirmed reservation until confirmed by our sales department) using the form below, or call our group sales office at 1-800-791-9083.
Please note that we also offer event space for those looking for buffet, plated or family-style dining for their special event – rehearsal dinners, weddings, anniversary parties, corporate events and more.

Reservation Request

Please complete the reservation request form below for groups. Reservations are required.

NOTE: Completing this form does not finalize your reservation. A sales representative will contact you with 1-3 days by email or phone to finalize the details of your reservation. Please check your spam folder. 

20 people or more

  • :
  • Please enter a value greater than or equal to 20.