Traditional Amish Farm Feast Menu

Since 1959,  Lancaster County’s original Family-Style Restaurant

Our Traditional Family-Style Amish Family Farm Feast for Groups of 20 or more. Reservations required. Plain & Fancy Restaurant serves an amazing menu of traditional Lancaster County PA Dutch food. Plus, you can stop to shop in the Plain & Fancy Country store before or after your meal and pick up some Lancaster County specialty foods to take home with you.

Here is the January to October 2024 menu:


  • House Salad with Dressing
  • Rolls with Butter
  • Cole Slaw


  • Made-from-scratch Golden Fried Chicken
  • Roast Eye Round of Beef with Au Jus
  • Beef Meatloaf


  • Real Mashed Potatoes with Gravy
  • Browned Buttered Noodles
  • Green Beans


  • 2 Desserts Freshly Made In-House

Bottomless Beverages:

  • Lemonade
  • Brewed Iced Tea
  • Hot Tea
  • Coffee (Regular and Decaf)
  • Water

Menu subject to change. In November & December, we will be serving our Holiday Feast.


All our food is made from scratch, using traditional PA Dutch recipes. Pennsylvania Dutch food is wholesome comfort food with stick-to-your-ribs dishes that are made from scratch with plenty of love and care. We serve family style as food is about sharing, family, and spending time together. If you haven’t done a family style Pennsylvania Dutch meal, what are you waiting for? Put in your reservation request and come down to Amish County! Don’t have 20 people, then consider Miller’s Smorgasbord where you can get Lancaster County favorites and more.