Groups of 20 or More

Announcing Our New, Hearty Plated Amish Dinners

Although Plain & Fancy is well-known for serving family-style to groups since 1959, when COVID-19 made national headlines in 2020, for the health and safety of our guests, we transitioned away from the traditional family-style dining to a hearty, plated option. This new dining style showcases the best of the best of our traditional family-style menu, featuring Lancaster County and guest favorites. We are confident groups will enjoy our new plated offerings!
For qualifying groups of 20 or more, discounted group rates are available. Payment must be made on one master bill. One complimentary meal for the group leader and one complimentary meal for a professional motorcoach driver (if applicable) will be provided. Plain & Fancy offers a large parking lot to accommodate motorcoaches.

Make a reservation request (note: this is not a confirmed reservation until confirmed by our sales department) using the form below, or call our group sales office at 1-800-791-9083.

Amish Dinner with Chicken & Sausage

  • Lancaster County Sampler (Chow Chow, Red Beet Egg with Red Beets, Pepper Relish and Cream Cheese with Crackers)
  • Roll with Butter
  • 2 Pieces Fried Chicken (breast and drum), Plain & Fancy’s Signature Baked Sausage
  • Real Mashed Potatoes with Gravy, Chef’s Choice of Vegetable
  • Choice of Dessert Made in House: Shoofly Cake with Whipped Topping or Cinnamon Cake with Fruit Topping and Caramel Drizzle (Selection made table-side)
  • Beverages Include: Iced Tea, Lemonade, Coffee/Decaf, Hot Tea and Water

Amish Dinner with Chicken & Eye Round of Beef

  • Lancaster County Sampler (Chow Chow, Red Beet Egg with Red Beets, Pepper Relish and Cream Cheese with Crackers)
  • Roll with Butter
  • 2 Pieces Fried Chicken (breast and drum) and Eye Round of Beef with Au Jus (cooked “medium”).
  • Real Mashed Potatoes with Gravy, Chef’s Choice of Vegetable
  • Choice of Dessert Made in House: Shoofly Cake with Whipped Topping or Cinnamon Cake with Fruit Topping and Caramel Drizzle (Selection made table-side)
  • Beverages Include: Iced Tea, Lemonade, Coffee/Decaf, Hot Tea and Water

Amish Dinner with Chicken & Meatloaf

  • Lancaster County Sampler (Chow Chow, Red Beet Egg with Red Beets, Pepper Relish and Cream Cheese with Crackers)
  • Roll with Butter
  • 2 Pieces Fried Chicken (breast and drum) and Beef Meatloaf
  • Real Mashed Potatoes with Gravy, Chef’s Choice of Vegetable
  • Choice of Dessert Made in House: Shoofly Cake with Whipped Topping or Cinnamon Cake with Fruit Topping and Caramel Drizzle (Selection made table-side)
  • Beverages Include: Iced Tea, Lemonade, Coffee/Decaf, Hot Tea and Water

2-Piece Fried Chicken Platter

  • Roll with Butter, Coleslaw
  • 2 Pieces Fried Chicken (breast and drum), Real Mashed Potatoes with Gravy, Chef’s Choice of Vegetable
  • Dessert Made In House: Shoofly Cake with Whipped Topping
  • Beverages Include: Lemonade, Iced Tea, Water and Coffee/Decaf

Student Menu

  • Roll with Butter
  • 2 Pieces Fried Chicken, Plain & Fancy’s Signature Baked Sausage
  • Real Mashed Potatoes with Gravy, Corn
  • Choice of Dessert Made in House: Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Ice Cream or Shoofly Cake with Vanilla Ice Cream
  • Beverages Include: Iced Tea, Lemonade, Coffee/Decaf, Hot Tea and Water

Please note, because we are preparing our plated meal specifically for the members of your group, counts will be confirmed two weeks, and again one week, prior to arrival. Should you have a count change greater than 10% of your confirmed count on the day of arrival, you will be charged for the guests who did not show.

Chalk Talk with Elva Hurst (add-on experience)

Chalk Talk is a wonderful add-on experience for parties of 25+ in conjunction with the purchase of a group meal at Plain & Fancy Farm Restaurant. Guests will be engaged through music, storytelling and the amazing chalk artistry of a former Old Order Mennonite woman who offers insights into Amish cuture with a story that comes to life and lights up before your eyes! It’s an experience sure to enchant and enthrall people of all ages.

Reservation Request

Please complete the reservation request form below for groups. Reservations are required.

NOTE: Completing this form does not finalize your reservation. A sales representative will contact you by email or phone to finalize the details of your reservation.

20 people or more

  • :
  • Please enter a value greater than or equal to 20.