Groups of 20 or More

We’re Thrilled to Return to our All-You-Care-to-Eat Family-Style Meal!

Since 1959, Plain & Fancy is well-known for serving family-style to groups. When COVID-19 made national headlines in 2020, we transitioned away from traditional family-style dining to a hearty, plated option, for the health and safety of our guests. As we navigated unprecedented times along with the rest of the world, we monitored guidelines and trends, while also keeping a pulse on guests’ comfortability. Guests began asking when Family-Style would return, and we’re excited to bring back the dining style that we’re known for, in 2023!

For qualifying groups of 20 or more, discounted group rates are available. Payment must be made on one master bill. One complimentary meal for the group leader and one complimentary meal for a professional motorcoach driver (if applicable) will be provided. Plain & Fancy offers a large parking lot to accommodate motor coaches.


Amish Family-Style Menu

  • Rolls with Butter, Coleslaw
  • Fried Chicken, Eye Round of Beef and Meatloaf
  • Mashed Potatoes with Gravy, Brown Buttered Noodles, Green Beans
  • Two Desserts Made in House
  • Beverages Include: Iced Tea, Lemonade, Coffee/Decaf, Hot Tea and Water
Make a reservation request (note: this is not a confirmed reservation until confirmed by our sales department) using the form below, or call our group sales office at 1-800-791-9083.

Reservation Request

Please complete the reservation request form below for groups. Reservations are required.

NOTE: Completing this form does not finalize your reservation. A sales representative will contact you by email or phone to finalize the details of your reservation.

20 people or more

  • :
  • Please enter a value greater than or equal to 20.