"Awesome!" Reviewed, Yelp, June 6, 2013
Awesome! Chicken so juicy and tasty! Amazing food! The fried chicken and Apple crisp were to die for!!

"Best family style restaurant in Lancaster." Reviewed, TripAdvisor, June 17, 2013
Best family style restaurant in Lancaster. A lot of yummy foods to choose from...something for everyone's taste. Best entrees that relate to Amish cooking. Eat all you can! Desserts top it off.

"My son and I did the ale cart menu at Plain and Fancy." Reviewed, TripAdvisor, May 14, 2013
My son and I did the ale cart menu at Plain and Fancy. He ordered the spicy chicken wrap and I had the special which was Beef Stroganoff. Both were very good. We also had the local craft beer which was also very good. Highly recommend for all tourists coming to Lancaster County.

"Best fried chicken ever!" Facebook Post, February 14, 2013
Been here. Ate here. Best fried chicken ever! Not to mention the shoofly pie.